Heavy brown paper and silver paint. I like a flat back so it resembles a texas star, but you can make a 3D version with both sides folded. Template: http://images.marthastewart.com/images/content/web/pdfs/2008Q4/msl_1298_glitterstar_template.pdf
Handmade Christmas gift tags using Stampin' Up! products - Many Merry Stars Simply Created Kit, Metallic Baker's Twine, and 1/4" Circle Handheld Punch. By Michele Reynolds, Inspiration Ink, http://inspirationink.typepad.com/inspiration-ink/2014/12/many-merry-stars-simply-created-kit-ideas.html.