REALLY WANT IT :: Ulta Essence Stay With Me Long-Lasting Lipgloss in My Favorite Milkshake :: $1.49 - $2.99 | ulta.com :: MOISTURIZING & PIGMENTED! My Favorite Milkshade is a "light, warm, natural pink w/ medium opacity. Thick, but moisturizing...similar to MAC Creamsheen Glass or MAC Lipglass w/o the stickiness. Because it's thicker, the wear time is pretty good. Great formula.